Jefferson v Marshall, an historical debate now sounding very contemporary

September 24, 2019

Several constitutional and political issues that continue to surface these days have been with us from the very founding of our nation. 

It may be rare, however, except in a classroom perhaps, to hear vigorous, thorough discussion of federalism and states’ rights, judicial review and constraints on executive power.

And so, it was a special privilege to attend a staged debate between two actors portraying President Thomas Jefferson and Chief Justice John Marshall, two of our nation’s seminal political figures. 

The actors appeared on the stage at the Morristown National Historical Park in September, dressed for their roles and earnestly using the words of the two men. They pressed each other on issues that go to the very heart of a constitutional republic.

Linda Stamato, of Morristown, is co-director of the Center for Negotiation and Conflict Resolution, and a member of the graduate faculty at the Edward J. Bloustein School. Her blog appears regularly on NJ.com. She can be reached at lstamato@ejb.rutgers.edu

The Bernardsville News, September 23, 2019

Recent Posts

VTC and CUPR Compile NJ Infrastructure Needs Assessment

Read the Report Introduction The New Jersey State Planning Act (N.J.S.A. 52:18A-196 et. seq.) requires that the State Planning Commission “prepare and adopt as part of the State Plan a long-term Infrastructure Needs Assessment, which shall provide information on...

Pallavi Shinde (MCRP ’12) Featured in Planning Magazine

Pallavi Shinde (MCRP ’12), Planning and Zoning Director for Newark, is featured on the cover of Planning Magazine (American Planning Association), Winter 2026 edition. The cover story highlights Newark’s leadership in adaptive reuse, showcasing how underutilized...

Announcing the Passing of Donald Sutton

The Bloustein School is saddened to announce the passing of Donald Sutton, former Assistant Dean for External Affairs and Director of Development, on October 13, 2025. Don was hired by Rutgers—New Brunswick in 2006 to serve as Director of Development at the School of...

NJSPL: Safer E-Biking and Understanding Micromobility

Safer E-Biking: What Parents, Youth, and Communities Should Know about Micromobility in New Jersey Leigh Ann Von Hagen, Hannah Younes, Sean Meehan, Julia Kohn As e-bikes and other micromobility devices like e-scooters and e-motorcycles become increasingly popular,...

Dean Shapiro: Two Key Steps to Get Rid of the Sludge

By Dean Stuart Shapiro There are two related steps that the administration could take to target sludge across the government. Cass Sunstein has defined “sludge” as the friction created by the unnecessary paperwork burdens inhibiting access to government programs....