Physician assistant, nurse practitioner or doctor: What patients should know

August 21, 2023

The nurse practitioner will see you now.

It’s not the phrase most people are accustomed to hearing, but it’s increasingly the case, with patients more likely than ever to see providers with advanced degrees, such as physician assistants and nurse practitioners, instead of doctors.

The physician shortage, a growing demand on health care and more people graduating with advanced degrees helped expand their presence at physicians’ offices. But what does that mean for patients?

Data shows patients have similar health outcomes regardless of whether they see a physician, physician assistant or nurse practitioner in primary care settings, but the jury is still out in other settings, like emergency departments and specialty care.

As providers with advanced degrees become more prevalent in health care facilities, experts say more research needs to be done and conversations had to determine where and how their skills can be most beneficial.

“There’s a lot of medicine that requires the care of an M.D. but there’s a lot of medicine that doesn’t, and the key thing is to allocate providers to the places where they’re needed and likely to be most effective,” said Dr. Anupam B. Jena, professor at Harvard Medical School and co-author of the new book, “Random Acts of Medicine: The Hidden Forces That Sway Doctors, Impact Patients and Shape Our Health.”

Why there are more PAs and NPs

This shift to other types of medical professionals began about 20 years ago, health experts say, and the COVID-19 pandemic only accelerated it.

“It’s been more and more accepted that physician assistants and nurse practitioners are highly qualified professionals that can take on a lot of the work that’s traditionally done by physicians,” said Perri Morgan, physician assistant, and professor in family medicine and community health at Duke University School of Medicine.

In its 2023 report, U.S. News and World Report ranks nurse practitioner and physician assistant as the first- and second-best jobs in health care, respectively, after measuring qualities like compensation, job growth and stress levels, among others. A March 2022 study published in the Future Healthcare Journal found physician assistants are estimated to grow 35% by 2035.

These careers became more popular as the physician shortage increased already long wait times for doctor’s appointments, experts say. The average physician appointment wait time has risen 24% since 2004, from about 20 days to 26 days in 2022, according to a survey by Merritt Hawkins, a physician and advanced practitioner recruiting and consulting company.

Large hospital systems began hiring more physician assistants and nurse practitioners because there were more of them in the workforce, and they’re cheaper to hire compared with physicians, Morgan said.

While physicians require at least four years of medical school plus residency, physician assistants and nurse practitioners need only about two years for their advanced degrees. And unlike specialists, these advanced providers have more general training, which gives them the freedom to work in various health care settings.

“We’re not bound to any specialty, which is unique. Doctors spend so much time getting their specialty and they don’t move easily,” Morgan said. “When there’s a bigger need suddenly for one area, physician assistants can follow the market.”

Health outcomes: Are costs and patient care different?

Most research comparing patient outcomes between different providers has been limited to primary care settings.

One study set in community health centers analyzed nearly 24,000 patient visits over five years, looking at nine different patient outcomes and quality measures among physician assistants, nurse practitioners and primary care physicians.

Researchers found there was no statistical difference in seven out of the nine outcomes studied regardless of a patient’s provider, according to the June 2017 report published in Medical Care, a peer-reviewed journal from the American Public Health Association.

The quality measures in which study authors found a difference: Nurse practitioners were more likely to provide smoking cessation counseling and education services.

“That’s how nurse practitioners are trained. They’re trained to educate patients to make them as independent in their care as possible to promote self-care, prevention and health,” said Ellen Kurtzman, one of the study’s authors, and professor and executive director of health administration at Rutgers University Edward J. Bloustein School of Planning and Public Policy.

Another study, published June 2019 in Health Affairs, analyzed electronic health records of diabetes patients from Veterans Affairs clinics over two years and found nurse practitioners, physicians assistants and physicians achieved similar outcomes in helping patients control blood pressure, blood sugar and cholesterol.

“We focused on diabetes because it’s very common, very important and it’s a risk factor of other problems like heart failure,” said Morgan, who authored the study. “It accounts for a large percentage of health care costs and to manage diabetes well you need that partnership between the provider and patient.”

Researchers were also able to calculate costs and found the cost of care for patients was lower among nurse practitioners and physician assistants compared to physicians. The findings showed the difference in costs was largely driven by emergency department visits and hospitalizations among patients who had a physician.

“If the care that they provide is equivalent, there are opportunities to use advanced practice clinicians in ways that will save the country money and not threaten the quality of care,” Kurtzman said.

However, one paper that has yet to be published and peer-reviewed suggests a different story in emergency departments.

The report looks at clinical outcomes and costs of patients seen by a nurse practitioner or physician in Veteran Health Administration emergency rooms. Since the type of patient who comes to the emergency room is random and who they’re seeing is based on availability, the report could control for some biases found in primary care settings, said Jena, who is not affiliated with the study.

The paper found nurse practitioners used more resources to achieve worse patient outcomes compared with physicians. But that doesn’t mean physicians are always better than nurse practitioners, said the study’s author Dr. David Chan, associate professor of health policy at the Stanford School of Medicine and a physician at the VA Palo Alto Health Care System.

“It’s a nuanced point because there’s a lot of variation,” he said. “It’s important to ask how to use all these professions in teams and how they can all work together.”

How PAs and NPs can fill in gaps

Health experts say the best way physician assistants and nurse practitioners fit into the changing health care landscape is in a team setting alongside or under the supervision of physicians.

These advanced degree providers can be especially important in some of the fastest growing sectors of health care including mental and behavioral health, geriatrics, and rural medicine.

The paper found nurse practitioners used more resources to achieve worse patient outcomes compared with physicians. But that doesn’t mean physicians are always better than nurse practitioners, said the study’s author Dr. David Chan, associate professor of health policy at the Stanford School of Medicine and a physician at the VA Palo Alto Health Care System.

“It’s a nuanced point because there’s a lot of variation,” he said. “It’s important to ask how to use all these professions in teams and how they can all work together.”

How PAs and NPs can fill in gaps

Health experts say the best way physician assistants and nurse practitioners fit into the changing health care landscape is in a team setting alongside or under the supervision of physicians.

These advanced degree providers can be especially important in some of the fastest growing sectors of health care including mental and behavioral health, geriatrics, and rural medicine.

These advanced degree clinicians could also help provide care to the aging population as the youngest Baby Boomers finally age into Medicare by 2030, a generation the U.S. Census Bureau estimates is about 73 million people.

“As they age, we’re going to have a lot of more chronic medical concerns that will need to be treated and assessed,” said Dr. Sterling Ransone, board chair and former president of the American Academy of Family Physicians and a practicing rural family physician in Deltaville, Virginia.

Nurse practitioners and physician assistants are valued members of the team who can help alleviate some of that workload, he added.

And although the physician shortage is a nationwide problem, health experts say those living in rural or disenfranchised communities are feeling the worst effects as some patients lose their only provider within a drivable distance.

Over 100 million Americans, or one-third of the nation, don’t have access to a usual source of primary care due to a shortage of providers in their local community, according to an analysis by the National Association of Community Health Centers.

While physician assistants and nurse practitioners play a huge role in medicine, health experts say it’s important to not overlook their limitations.

“There’s a lot of places where nurse practitioners and physician assistants can probably do very well in health care but other places where they don’t,” Jena said. “It’s important not to overextend and put people in situations where they wouldn’t thrive in.”

USA Today, August 20, 2023

Recent Posts

Kelly O’Brien (MCRP ’09) Named Fairfax City Hometown Hero

On July 15th, Kelly O'Brien (MCRP '09)  was recognized as a Hometown Hero during Fox 5 DC's Zip Trip visit to Fairfax City. "Although I don't think of myself as a hero, I am grateful for the chance to express my dedication to serving my community and shed light on the...

Winecoff: Working Paper on Health Insurance Enrollment

Spillovers in Public Benefit Enrollment: How does Expanding Public Health Insurance for Working-Age Adults affect Future Health Insurance Choices? Abstract Enrollment in one public benefit program often affects enrollment in others. We study life-course spillovers by...

$21.1 million Awarded for the Safe Routes to School Program

The Murphy Administration announced $21.1 million for 23 grants under the Safe Routes to School (SRTS) program on July 10, 2024. The New Jersey Safe Routes to School Program, supported by the New Jersey Department of Transportation, is a statewide initiative with a...

Deanna Moran Named MA Chief Coastal Resilience Officer

Deanna Moran, AICP (MPP/MCRP '16) was named the Chief Coastal Resilience Officer by the Healey-Driscoll Administration to address climate change impacts along Massachusetts’ coastline. Energy and Environmental Affairs (EEA) Secretary Rebecca Tepper announced Deanna...

Voorhees Transportation Center seeks new Executive Director

The Alan M. Voorhees Transportation Center (VTC) seeks a new Executive Director who will oversee the center’s research program, technical services and other initiatives, including external relations, communications, business development, and fundraising. The Executive...

Upcoming Events

Event Series CAREERS

Virtual Career Drop-ins

Virtual

Stop by virtually on Mondays (except for holidays) beginning September 9th through December 16th between 11 am and 1 pm to ask a quick (15 min) career-related question of Bloustein […]