Harvard and the false premise of meritocratic university admissions

August 10, 2017

The debate over affirmative action in college admissions has taken a new twist: The Justice Department is seeking lawyers for investigations and possible lawsuits against universities to prohibit what they deem is “intentional race-based discrimination.”

Last year, the Supreme Court ruled in a University of Texas case that school officials can consider race in making admissions decisions, upholding the value of having a racially diverse student body. But affirmative action critics say there is still legal room to challenge such policies, and there are cases now pending at the University of North Carolina and Harvard University, both accusing the school of discrimination against Asian Americans.

This piece looks at one of those lawsuits and about a basic problem with the way merit in admissions is determined in the first place. It was written by  Julia Sass Rubin, an associate professor at the Edward J. Bloustein School of Planning and Public Policy at Rutgers University.

Harvard and the false premise of meritocratic university admissions
The Washington Post, August 10, 2017

Recent Posts

Meet the 2026 New Jersey Leadership Collective Fellows

New Jersey Leadership Collective’s mission is to train leaders who are committed to moving the communities they serve and the Garden State forward. They aim to make progressive change to legislation and policies through building collective power and taking collective...

EJB Talks: Fighting for Government Accountability in NJ

From Corruption to Ballot Reform: Fighting for Government Accountability in New Jersey As we close out our 13th season of EJB Talks, Dean Stuart Shapiro asks Public Policy Program Director, Professor Julia Rubin, about why New Jersey has long been considered one of...

New 2024-2025 Health Administration Program Annual Report

Dear Colleagues, This year’s milestone is the successful launch of our Doctor of Health Administration (DHA) program in Fall 2025, welcoming an inaugural cohort of 23 mid- and senior-level healthcare leaders. Designed in an executive-style format, the DHA advances...

Heldrich Center: Updated Multi-State Postsecondary Report Released

The Heldrich Center for Workforce Development has announced the release of an updated Multi-State Postsecondary Report, linking postsecondary completion data to employment outcomes across Kentucky, New Jersey, Ohio, Rhode Island, Tennessee, and Virginia. This effort...

Cantor, Yedidia Identify Strategies to Provide Health Care to Homeless

Through cooperation, homeless services and health care providers can improve delivery of medical care to a vulnerable population, according to Rutgers researchers published by Rutgers Today, December 17, 2025 Author: Greg Bruno Media Contact: Nicole Swenarton, Rutgers...