Ditching your car may be great for the planet, but it can take a pick-axe to your income — try going ‘car-lite’ instead

August 1, 2023

Bikes can cost anywhere from $400 to $3,500, depending on your budget and your needs. Even a brand-new, high-end bike costs about 90% less than the average used car. Public transit costs vary, but one household can save $10,000 a year by using public transportation instead of a car. And walking is free, other than perhaps a good pair of shoes.

Long-term economic costs to car-free living

Besides the hidden costs of going car-free, there are also long-term negative economic consequences, said Michael Smart, an associate professor at Rutgers University who studies automobile ownership.

Smart’s research shows that families with a car experience an average income growth of 1% every two years. But car-free households experience an average income decline of 7% during that same time period. Smart said this is because people without cars can’t commute as easily to work, making them more likely to be late, unreliable, or unable to take certain jobs. And that can hurt their income.

“The high cost of owning a vehicle is probably lower than the cost of living without one,” Smart and his coauthors wrote in a 2021 paper, “The Poverty of the Carless.”

Smart himself never got a driver’s license because of his environmental convictions. He even managed to live car-free for years in the notoriously auto-dependent Los Angeles. But he also understands that he’s an anomaly.

“I would like people to drive less, but I have tremendous sympathy and understanding for why people drive so much,” he told Insider. “We’ve set up society to strongly encourage — and in some cases, really demand — that you drive a lot.”

Business Insider, Aug 1, 2023

Recent Posts

Elizabeth (Libby) Vinson (MPAP ’02) Named CEO of NJACP

From New Jersey Business Magazine, July 15, 2025 Vinson Named CEO of NJ Association of Community Providers The New Jersey Association of Community Providers (NJACP), Ewing, the statewide not-for-profit organization that represents community-based providers who care...

From Fear to Freedom and Hope: Rafael Escalante (UG PP ’26)

Pursuing a college education and the American dream, Rafael Escalante departed the embattled South American nation and made his way to New Jersey Rafael Escalante escaped politically motivated persecution as a teenager in Venezuela to find his place – and a brighter...

NJSPL: Mapping Corporate Landlords in New Jersey

by Eric Seymour As part of our ongoing research project supported by the New Jersey State Policy Lab, we are examining the growth of corporate ownership in the state’s small residential property market. Our focus is on 1- to 4-unit properties, which, in addition to...

Samuel and Colleagues Examine the Rise of AI Phobia

Abstract Contemporary public discourse surrounding artificial intelligence (AI) often exhibits a disproportionate level of fear and confusion relative to AI’s factually documented capabilities and implications. This study examines how the systematic use of alarmist...

Ralph, Johnson-Rodriguez Research ASE Perceptions

Do perceptions of speeding act as a barrier to automated speed enforcement in the United States? Highlights Many American adults do not believe speeding is particularly dangerous. Yet 65% of respondents believe their community should vote for automated speed...