NJSPL – Marc Pfeiffer On Fixing the Open Public Records Act

March 14, 2024

by Marc Pfeiffer for the New Jersey State Policy Lab

OPRA, the state’s Open Public Records Act is showing its age. Now 22 years old, this important public policy suffers, in part, from age, neglect, unintended consequences, and unexpected use cases. Over the years, it has received insufficient legislative attention that left unaddressed, judicial decisions that modified and interpreted key elements.

Over the years, the law’s intent has been unexpectedly undermined by technological changes (e.g., email, text messaging, AI-generated content), abuse of the law by outliers seeking financial gain, and costly financial and administrative burdens placed on government agencies, which are then passed on to local taxpayers. There is also an inadequate and inconsistent understanding of what constitutes the free flow of information in the public interest vs the privacy rights of the individual.

It has also seen an evolution of public expectations and suspicions of government, driven by technology/social media, local, state, and national politics, world events, and increased attention to and fascination with the accusations against unethical public officials. The result is an environment in which many people are increasingly distrustful and dubious of government processes. That leads them to demand more access to government records.

Efforts to repair OPRA must recognize that the law affects all levels of New Jersey government, not just municipal, though that seems to get the most public attention. It has become an indispensable element for:

  • the media and its essential role in holding government agencies accountable through records and data.
  • companies that use or repackage for sale government data which, which while possibly improving the economy, in some cases may violate privacy expectations.
  • non-profit advocacy groups that rely on public records for their work.
  • academicians who regularly work under strict confidentiality rules with sensitive data.
  • organizations that conduct business and negotiate contracts with government agencies.
  • members of the public with vested and public interests in government activities.

How can we solve the problems without a clear understanding of the issues and circumstances that need to be addressed? Using anecdotal reports based on problems that may or not be widespread or affect a single interest is not a sound approach. Policy problem-solving requires a process to identify the range of problems, understand their underlying causes, and assess their frequency and severity. At this link is my description of the questions surrounding OPRA and a process that may lead to potential solutions that address those critical challenges. Furthermore, you can download and read my analysis of eight key OPRA reform bill challenges here.

Recent Posts

Heldrich Center Releases New Work Trends Brief and Website

The Heldrich Center for Workforce Development is pleased to announce the availability of two new research products resulting from its long-running public opinion polling series, Work Trends. To better understand the public’s attitudes about work, employers, and the...

NJSPL Report: Analyzing the Use and Equity of ARPA Funds

Report Release: Analyzing the Use and Equity of ARPA Funds in NJ Local Governments and Beyond New Jersey State Policy Lab The American Rescue Plan Act’s Coronavirus State and Local Fiscal Recovery Funds (ARPA-SLFRF) represent a historic $350 billion investment to...

Dr. Grafova Presented Posters from the VSR Research

Dr. Irina Grafova recently returned from the AcademyHealth Research Meeting in Minneapolis, where she had the opportunity to present two posters from the Virtual Schwartz Rounds emotional support program for nurses, run by the New Jersey Nursing Emotional Well-being...

Heldrich Report: Analysis of NJ Life Sciences, Tech Sectors

The Heldrich Center, in conjunction with the New Jersey Economic Development Authority (NJEDA), is pleased to share a new workforce analysis of the life sciences and technology sectors in New Jersey, with a particular emphasis on the sectors’ intersection with...

Restrepo-Mieth Researches Tree Inventories in Galápagos, Ecuador

Who wants a tree inventory and why? The politics of inventorying urban forestry in Galápagos, Ecuador Abstract Trees make significant contributions to the urban experience by providing ecosystem services and aesthetic value. Considering these contributions, cities are...