Faculty research: Robert Lake examines whether pandemic could lead to sweeping social change

August 2, 2021

by Marcia Hannigan

In his essay, “We Have Been Here Before: Crisis, Response, and the Stasis of Urban Policy,” Bloustein School Professor Emeritus Robert W. Lake looks back a century to see if the global upheaval wrought by the COVID-19 pandemic can lead to sweeping social change.

For evidence from history, Dr. Lake looks to parallels in the aftermath of the flu pandemic of 1918 and World War I.  Such disruptions, he maintains, often generate “wild expectations” for change only to be followed by more of the same. 

Dr. Lake points out that the predictions for change made by experts and pundits often follow the political leanings of those tapped to offer predictions.  Commentators on the conservative end of the spectrum fear that an “overweening government”  will undermine the foundations of a free society while those on the left warn against populist rebellions and irremediable polarization.  Contrary to such apocalyptic projections, he shows that the expressed desire for a “return to normalcy” leads to the continuation of habits, systems, and ways of thought that reproduce hegemonic structures and existing power relations. 

As a historical example, Dr. Lake cites the American philosopher, psychologist, and educational reformer John Dewey’s assessment of the persistence of the status quo after the Great War and the continuing challenge to achieve meaningful social change in the lead up to World War II. Reflecting back on his optimistic predictions for change in 1918, Dewey wrote in 1939 that “The fact that these hopes were betrayed and objectives failed to be realized is evidence of our failure to take advantage of the opportunity that was unquestionably there.”   What were these hopes? The hope for a national minimum wage, the guarantee of the right to work, decent housing, and the expansion of workplace democracy—issues that continue to resonate to this day.  Dewey ascribed the failure to implement needed change to the desire for a “return to normalcy” following the dislocations of war and pestilence.

As Dr. Lake recounts, Dewey warned that needed change could not rely on “experts” offering short-term solutions in a top-down “planned” society. He advocated the mobilization of collective intelligence for a  bottom-up “continuously planning society” using “cooperative give-and-take” among a pluralistic and democratic public. This need persists today. As Lake concludes, “Today, in the aftermath of a global pandemic, the evils existing in Dewey’s time still exist now, the things needing to be done then still need to be done now.”

Recent Posts

Do you have one of the most common jobs in New Jersey?

Nearly 4.6 million people work in New Jersey in thousands of different types of jobs. But nearly 840,000 positions make up the top 10 most common roles, according to data from the U.S Bureau of Labor Statistics. Laborers and freight stock and material movers — those...

NJSPL – The New Jersey Induced Travel Calculator

By Robert B. Noland Induced travel occurs when new roads or lanes are built with the goal of reducing traffic congestion. What this means in practice is that new travel fills the new roads or lanes such that the goal of congestion reduction is not met. While many...

Kelly O’Brien (MCRP ’09) Named Fairfax City Hometown Hero

On July 15th, Kelly O'Brien (MCRP '09)  was recognized as a Hometown Hero during Fox 5 DC's Zip Trip visit to Fairfax City. "Although I don't think of myself as a hero, I am grateful for the chance to express my dedication to serving my community and shed light on the...

Winecoff: Working Paper on Health Insurance Enrollment

Spillovers in Public Benefit Enrollment: How does Expanding Public Health Insurance for Working-Age Adults affect Future Health Insurance Choices? Abstract Enrollment in one public benefit program often affects enrollment in others. We study life-course spillovers by...

$21.1 million Awarded for the Safe Routes to School Program

The Murphy Administration announced $21.1 million for 23 grants under the Safe Routes to School (SRTS) program on July 10, 2024. The New Jersey Safe Routes to School Program, supported by the New Jersey Department of Transportation, is a statewide initiative with a...

Upcoming Events

Event Series CAREERS

Virtual Career Drop-ins


Stop by virtually on Mondays (except for holidays) beginning September 9th through December 16th between 11 am and 1 pm to ask a quick (15 min) career-related question of Bloustein […]