Research: News coverage affects perceived blame in traffic crashes

March 6, 2021

by Marcia Hannigan

Have you ever wondered why we say, “a car hit a person” but we don’t say, “a hammer hit a person”?  Assistant professor Kelcie Ralph and Evan Iacobucci ( of the Edward J. Bloustein School of Planning and Public Policy, Rutgers University) worked with colleagues Dr. Calvin  Thigpen (of Lime) and Dr. Tara Goddard (Dept. of Landscape Architecture and Urban Planning, Texas A&M University) to examine the effects of language on how we perceive and respond to traffic crashes.

The full article, “Does news coverage of traffic crashes affect perceived blame and preferred solutions?  Evidence from an experiment” and is available for free via Open Access in the journal Transportation Research Interdisciplinary Perspectives.

In previous research, the team reviewed 200 news articles describing car crashes involving people walking (n=100) or biking (n=100).  The authors identified two recurring problems. The first problem occurs at the sentence-level, where seemingly minor choices consistently shift the blame towards the person walking or biking even when the events leading up to the crash were unclear.  For instance, journalists repeatedly used the phrase “a pedestrian was hit” to describe a crash. This sentence commits two sins. First, it assigns agency to an inanimate object. Until self-driving cars are available, this phrase has no place in crash reporting.

To illustrate the awkwardness of this phrase, consider a case where someone gets hit by another person swinging a hammer. The news report would not say, “person hit by hammer.” It would say, “someone hit a person with a hammer.” The second sin is that the sentence makes the person walking or biking the focus of the sentence—the star of the show. Linguistics studies suggest that that the focus of the sentence receives more blame. Another recurring sentence-level problem was the widespread use of the word “accident” instead of “crash”, which further obscures the fact that crashes are preventable.

To determine whether these minor linguistic issues actually matter, the authors conducted an experiment where participants read a news story about a crash and answered questions about who bore responsibility for the crash. 

Readers who encountered standard coverage tended to blame the pedestrian. Some readers encountered a slightly modified description of the crash that used crash, made the driver the focus of sentences, and avoided object-based language. Those readers were much less likely to blame the pedestrian for the crash. 

The experiment also provided evidence about the perverse effect of the second major problem in crash coverage.  Existing coverage tends to treat crashes as isolated events. An alternative approach is to frame crashes thematically by reporting crash statistics and highlighting the common elements in many crashes (high speeds and unsafe road design). By reporting on crashes in isolation, existing coverage obscures the fact that crashes are predictable and preventable. It also reduces the sense of urgency to address crashes because readers have no information about how often crashes lead to serious injuries and deaths.

When readers were exposed to thematically framed articles with crash statistics and a description of the roadway, readers shifted their blame from the pedestrian to features of the roadway. These readers were also more likely to support systems-based solutions to improving road safety like reducing speed limits and changing street design.

This study demonstrates that simple editorial changes can positively affect how readers interpret car crashes. Simple, inexpensive changes can reduce victim-blaming and increase support for evidence-based safety improvements.     

Recent Posts

Nikpour Receives Office of Disability Services Award

Professor Fereydoun Nikpour was selected for the Office of Disability Services Faculty Honor Roll. The Faculty Honor Roll is a new initiative to recognize instructors who go above and beyond to support the work of the Office of Disability Services (ODS). ODS staff...

Heldrich Report: NJ’s Energy-Efficiency Workforce Needs

New Jersey's Energy-Efficiency Workforce Needs, Infrastructure, and Equity Assessment New Jersey Governor Phil Murphy’s Energy Master Plan and Executive Order 315 set a goal to reduce fossil fuel usage to 100% clean energy by 2035. The Executive Order also called for...

Shaul Picker Receives 2024 Mortensen-Voorhees Award

Shaul Picker is the 2024 recipient of the Mortensen-Voorhees Award for Achievement in Transportation Studies. This award is granted annually to the highest-achieving student with a concentration in transportation at the Edward J. Bloustein School of Urban Planning and...

NJSPL – Key Insights from Early Offshore Wind Implementation

By Jessica Parineet Offshore wind development is in its early stages in the United States, with just under one gigawatt (GW) of utility scale capacity constructed. State decarbonization goals have catalyzed industry progress thus far, however the Biden administration...

EJB Talks: Political Update with Stuart Shapiro and Amy Cobb

Analyzing Trump's Guilty Verdict and the 2024 Election Outlook Stuart Shapiro welcomes back Amy Cobb MPAP '18 for a political update in the final EJB Talks episode of the spring 2024 season. They discuss the potential consequences of Trump's guilty verdict for...

Upcoming Events

Latest Past Events

Jersey City Alumni Mixer

Zeppelin Hall Biergarten 88 Liberty View Dr, Jersey City

Join us for an alumni mixer in #JerseyCity on Thursday, June 6th at Zeppelin Hall Biergarten. Parking for Zeppelin Hall is FREE - more information can be found here: https://zeppelinhall.com/map/. This […]