Dr. Will Payne Examines Consequences of Review Bombing

September 30, 2024

Review bombing the platformed city: Contested political speech in online local reviews

Abstract

Local review platforms like Yelp and Google Maps use systems combining automated and human judgment to delineate the limits of acceptable speech, allowing some reviews to remain public and removing or obscuring others. This article examines the phenomenon of “review bombing,” in which controversial businesses receive an influx of reviews, using spatiotemporal analysis of review activity to analyze their shifting catchment areas, measuring what sociologist Richard Ocejo calls the “extraterritoriality” of their “taste communities”. Specifically, this article examines businesses in the United States that are caught up in political controversies using the locations of their consumer-reviewers on Yelp. The author compiles a test dataset of affected businesses encompassing national and local politics, including the 2016 and 2020 U.S. elections, the #BlackLivesMatter and #MeToo movements, and the COVID-19 pandemic, and selects two for in-depth case studies and spatial analysis: Washington, D.C.-based pizzeria Comet Ping Pong (subject of the #Pizzagate conspiracy theory) and St. Louis-based Pi Pizzeria (caught up in debates about policing and the Black Lives Matter movement). In Comet Ping Pong’s case, review bombing resulted in a wider spatial distribution of primarily negative reviewers, while Pi has a much more local pattern, with a fairly even split of supporters and detractors, showing how different political controversies resonate across different scales. The article contrasts Yelp’s interventionist approach to content moderation to the relatively laissez-faire attitude of competitors like Google, and considers the consequences of this form of “algorithmic censorship” for small businesses, communities, and online speech.

Citation

Payne, W. B. (2024). Review bombing the platformed city: Contested political speech in online local reviews. Big Data & Society11(3). https://doi.org/10.1177/20539517241275879

Recent Posts

New Report – State of the Climate: New Jersey 2024

Overview The State of the Climate: New Jersey report annually summarizes updated scientific information on climate trends and projections that can be used by state and local decision-makers, researchers, hazard planning and climate resilience professionals, and...

NJSPL: How E-Bikes Could Bridge the Healthcare Gap

by Yingning Xie Pedaling Toward Access: How E-Bikes Could Bridge the Healthcare Gap Imagine needing medical care but being sidelined by the simple fact that you can’t get to your provider. In New Jersey, and across the U.S., accessing healthcare and wellness support...

“Work Trends RU” Podcast with Rachel Korberg

This week's guest on the Heldrich Center's Work Trends RU podcast is Rachel Korberg, Executive Director and Co-Founder of the Families and Workers Fund. Rachel is also a member of the Heldrich Center’s National Advisory Board. In this episode, Rachel shares: The...

Report Release: R/ECON Forecast Summer 2025

Read Report R/ECON’s economic forecast for New Jersey as of mid-2025 continues to show a slowing trajectory. Annual GDP growth is projected at just 0.5% for 2025, significantly lower than in prior forecasts and markedly below the national rate of 1.5%. Growth will...

New Publication from Payne: Digital Twin or Digital Kin?

Digital Twin or Digital Kin: Misunderstandings and Myths about Urban Simulation, and Directions for Change Abstract Using three case studies from the United States and Australia, this article explores the conditions required to make urban digital twin projects...