Research: Local planners do have agency in leveraging real estate markets to finance public goods

March 11, 2021

by Marcia Hannigan

It is now commonplace to say that cities are in the grips of real estate capital. Bloustein School associate professor Mi Shih, PhD and Leslie Shieh, PhD (Tomo Spaces, Canada) argue that local planners do have agency in leveraging real estate markets to finance public goods (roads, parks, community centers, etc.). They build their argument by examining two density-based value-capture mechanisms: community amenity contributions (CAC) in Vancouver, Canada and transfer of development rights (TDR) in New Taipei City, Taiwan in their article “Negotiating Density and Financing Public Goods in Vancouver and New Taipei City: A Development Rights Perspective,” in Planning Practice & Research 2020 (Vol. 35, N4. 4, 380–395

Land value capture can be broadly understood as planners extracting some of the values from the granting of additional density to private real estate development projects for public benefits. Their article examines the key differences between Vancouver’s CAC and New Taipei City’s TDR in terms of the design of their respective land-value capture mechanism, negotiating dynamics, actors involved, and the types of public goods financed. Mi and Leslie argue that to understand the differences in outcome, it is necessary to first question how different perspectives on development rights guide and shape planners’ use of density. Drawing from multi-disciplinary scholarship, they engage in a theoretical discussion of three perspectives: absolute ownership, which emphasizes the centrality of private land ownership; bundle of rights, which balances multiple interests; and public assets, which relies on the state’s power of coordination.

Using the three perspectives as a framework, they show that Vancouver’s CAC reflects the public asset perspective where the logic of the private market does not entirely dictate the financing of public facilities. Whether a rezoning application is approved, how much value the uplift is worth, and the type of public benefits to be provided is determined in a dynamic negotiation process involving multiple social actors. Vancouver planners play a key role in this complex process by weighing planning priorities, community impact and needs, and development finance. Vancouver approaches rezoning in a more municipality-coordinated and community-centered process.

New Taipei City’s TDR embodies the absolute ownership perspective where development rights are treated as a commodity for trading. In addition, TDR approval process is relatively closed-off to local residents. The amount of density bonus is determined by a general formula, and the location of TDR development projects is decided by the developer’s market-driven decisions. Local residents are usually unaware of whether, and to what extent, the increased vertical development in their neighborhood is made possible through TDR and whether there are additional amenities to support this growth.

Mi and Leslie’s work demonstrates that planners do have a crucial role to play in leveraging the private real estate market for larger public benefits. However, while land-value capture mechanisms work to extract monetary value from additional density, they do not necessarily hold the same perspective on who owns and who benefits from development rights. To ensure that land value capture is in line with a larger social engagement process, planners do need to look deeply and question the underlying perspective on development rights they hold in guiding their practices.

Recent Posts

Prof. Julia Sass Rubin: Advocate for Democracy

Original article published in TAPintoPrinceton, June 15, 2024 By Pam Hersh Princeton, NJ – Tuesday, June 4, Primary Election Day in New Jersey, was a big expletive-deleted deal for Princeton resident Julia Sass Rubin, whose name appeared nowhere on any ballot. Rubin,...

Nikpour Receives Office of Disability Services Award

Professor Fereydoun Nikpour was selected for the Office of Disability Services Faculty Honor Roll. The Faculty Honor Roll is a new initiative to recognize instructors who go above and beyond to support the work of the Office of Disability Services (ODS). ODS staff...

Heldrich Report: NJ’s Energy-Efficiency Workforce Needs

New Jersey's Energy-Efficiency Workforce Needs, Infrastructure, and Equity Assessment New Jersey Governor Phil Murphy’s Energy Master Plan and Executive Order 315 set a goal to reduce fossil fuel usage to 100% clean energy by 2035. The Executive Order also called for...

Shaul Picker Receives 2024 Mortensen-Voorhees Award

Shaul Picker is the 2024 recipient of the Mortensen-Voorhees Award for Achievement in Transportation Studies. This award is granted annually to the highest-achieving student with a concentration in transportation at the Edward J. Bloustein School of Urban Planning and...

NJSPL – Key Insights from Early Offshore Wind Implementation

By Jessica Parineet Offshore wind development is in its early stages in the United States, with just under one gigawatt (GW) of utility scale capacity constructed. State decarbonization goals have catalyzed industry progress thus far, however the Biden administration...

Upcoming Events

Latest Past Events

Jersey City Alumni Mixer

Zeppelin Hall Biergarten 88 Liberty View Dr, Jersey City

Join us for an alumni mixer in #JerseyCity on Thursday, June 6th at Zeppelin Hall Biergarten. Parking for Zeppelin Hall is FREE - more information can be found here: This […]